Correlation: Engagement rate & ROI
In order to visualise the insights better we categorised the influencers into the following three segments:
- HP (High Performers): Influencers with >10 conversions / post
- MP (Medium Performers): Influencers with 3 - 9 conversions / post
- GP (General / Low Performers): Influencers with <3 conversions / post
The chart on the right visualises the median engagement rate for high, medium and low performing influences, showing a strong correlation to conversions and hence ROI. Based on this research we recommend to always analyse this metric before allocating budgets in order to optimise your influencer campaign for ROI.
Correlation: Engagements & ROI
Another metric we looked at in our research is engagements in absolute numbers. What is important to note here is to use this metric with a pinch of salt as it doesn't take the audience size into account when comparing influencers. This is why an influencer with a larger following has in most cases a higher number of engagements which raises the question if audience size (spoiler: which has a correlation with conversion, more on this in the next section) is the leading variable in this case or engagements. Nevertheless, it can be an important metric to look at as the chart on the left shows a significant difference across high, medium and low performing influencers and engagements.
What is a good Instagram influencer engagement rate?
To avoid comparing apples with oranges we have created a benchmark overview for you. Based on the data of 150M+ Instagram influencers we computed this overview so you can benchmark the influencers you want to work with.
Median Engagement Rate on Instagram
The median engagement rate across all influencer accounts is 1.47% ( calculated based on our own database, last updated Jan. 2024). When analysing metrics like engagement rate it is always important to look at the context and comparing the metric to others to fully understand the impact. To provide more data backed answers our data scientists analysed over 10,000 commercial influencer posts to compute the correlation between various metrics and ROI.
Which Other Metrics To analyse for ROI?
Audience Growth
One of the most significant findings from the research we conducted is the impact of audience growth on conversions. From the chart on the left it is visible that HP: high performing influencers (>10 conversions per sponsored social media post) had a significantly higher (>3X) growth in followers / audience compared to MP: medium performing influencers ( 3 - 10 conversions per sponsored social media post). While low performing influencers ( 0 - 2 conversions per sponsored social media post), even experienced a decline in their audience. This also makes sense as social media platforms in this case Meta reward high quality content while inactive or low quality content will lead to a decline or lower growth in followers, making audience growth an important metric to analyse when allocating budgets.
Audience size / Number of followers
One metric which is probably the most intuitive one is audience size. This is also important for the ongoing debate if micro and nano influencers are more effective than macro and mega influencers. The research we conducted where we analysed over 10,000 commercial influencer posts revealed that influencers with follower country exceeding the 75th percentile (over 96,731 followers) yielded better results. This is clearly visible in the chart on the left showing that the median follower size of high performing influencers is above 100K. Note: this doesn't directly answer the question on whether you should work with macro of micro influencers. As larger influencers are in most cases more expensive to work with the impact on ROI will depend on the cost of working with these influencers.
Fake Followers
According to recent estimates, Instagram has about 95 million bot accounts, which represents roughly 10% of all accounts on the platform. The last thing you want is to pay an influencer a lot of money just to reach fake followers. Our research shows that high performing influencers (>10 conversions per post) indeed have a lower % of fake followers. What is important to understand is that a certain % of bot following is inevitable especially with larger accounts. If the number of bots following is high however this can be a red flag. The result of our research shows that Influencers whose audience credibility was above the median score of 73.17% saw enhanced conversion rates. You can use our free influencer fake follower check to analyse this metric.
Verified Accounts
The last variable we analysed is the blue verified checkmark which Meta provides to official accounts. As you can see from the chart on the right 61.1% of HP: high performing influencers had a verified account, followed by 34.4% for MP: medium performing influencers and 26.7% for GP: General / Low performing influencers. Important: correlation doesn't imply causation. For example larger accounts tend to be verified more frequently, the underlying metric which leads to higher conversions could be size or another metric. Nevertheless, it could be a valuable metric to look at when allocating budgets for your influencer campaign.
How does Influencer Hero use this data to improve results?
Based on all these findings our data scientists blended all the metrics which showed a correlation to conversion and ROI into a conversion enhancing filter. When using our influencer search & discovery feature you can layer over our conversion enhancing filter to start with with influencers which have the highest potential to result in more sales.
What is an Influencer engagement rate?
An Influencer Engagement Rate on Instagram is a critical benchmark used to gauge how actively an influencer's audience interacts with their content specifically on this popular social media platform. It measures the level of audience participation through actions like likes, comments, and shares relative to the influencer’s number of followers.
A high engagement rate on Instagram indicates an influencer’s ability to effectively communicate and connect with their audience, making them more attractive to brands seeking to leverage influencers for marketing campaigns. It reflects not just reach, but the depth of an influencer's influence, demonstrating their followers' willingness to interact and engage with their content.
The importance of engagement rate for marketeers
Analyzing the engagement rate when working with influencers is crucial for several reasons, primarily to ensure marketing efforts are channeled through individuals who genuinely resonate with their audience. First, engagement rate serves as a direct indicator of an influencer's ability to actively engage and influence their followers, beyond mere follower count, which can sometimes be misleading due to inactive or fake followers. A high engagement rate signifies a loyal and interested audience, more likely to trust the influencer's recommendations, thereby increasing the chances of successful conversions for the brand.
Analyzing engagement rates allows brands to better forecast the potential return on investment (ROI) of their influencer marketing campaigns, optimizing their strategies for maximum impact. In essence, it ensures that brands collaborate with influencers who can effectively communicate their message, creating authentic interactions and driving tangible results.
Factors which impact the engagement rate
When calculating and analyzing engagement rate, it's crucial to take into account a comprehensive set of elements to ensure an accurate measure of an influencer's interaction level with their audience.
- 1. Likes
A fundamental measure of content approval and enjoyment. - 2. Comments
Provide a deeper insight into how the audience feels about the content, indicating a higher level of engagement. - 3. Shares
The ability for content to be redistributed by followers, signal that the content is valued - 4. Saves
Especially on platforms like Instagram, the number of times a post is saved is a strong indicator of the content's value - 5. Followers/Following Ratio
While not a direct engagement metric, examining the ratio of followers to following can provide context about the influencer’s reach and influence. - 6. Views
For video content, including Instagram stories, reels, YouTube videos, etc., the number of views is crucial for understanding engagement. - 7. Click-through Rates (CTR)
On platforms where clickable links can be shared (e.g., Instagram stories, YouTube descriptions), CTR can indicate how compelling and effective the call-to-action is. - 8. Engagement growth over time
Tracking how engagement rates change over time can reveal trends, content fatigue, or increased resonance with the audience.
To accurately assess an influencer's engagement rate, consider each of these elements as part of a whole. Simply put, engagement is more than just likes and comments—it's a multifaceted measure that reflects the audience's overall interaction and interest in an influencer's content. Understanding these nuances helps brands and marketers to not only choose the right influencers for their campaigns but also to gauge the potential impact and ROI of their influencer partnerships.
What can an Instagram influencer do to increase their engagement rate?
Instagram influencers aiming to boost their engagement rate can employ a number of tactics to stimulate more active involvement and interest from their audience. Here are effective strategies influencers can leverage:
- Post High-Quality Images and Videos: Content quality matters greatly on Instagram, so ensure that your photos and videos are visually appealing and high-resolution to capture attention.
- Engage With Followers: Actively respond to comments and direct messages to create a sense of community and show your audience that their engagement is valued.
- Use Engaging Captions: Craft captions that invite conversation, ask questions, or encourage followers to tag their friends, fostering engagement directly from your post's text.
- Incorporate Relevant Hashtags: Use hashtags strategically to reach a broader audience, making your posts more discoverable and encouraging engagement from new followers.
- Post Consistently: Keeping a regular posting schedule can help maintain audience interest and anticipation for your content, which can enhance engagement.
- Utilize Instagram Stories: Stories offer a dynamic way to engage with your audience through polls, questions, and interactive stickers, keeping your followers actively involved.
- Share Behind-The-Scenes Content: Giving your audience a glimpse into your life or the work that goes into creating your content can humanize your brand and increase engagement.
- Host Giveaways and Contests: Encourage followers to engage with your content through likes, comments, and shares for a chance to win something, boosting overall engagement.
- Collaborate with Other Influencers: Engage in shoutouts or collaborations with peers to tap into new audiences and invite fresh engagement.
- Leverage Instagram Live: Use the live feature to interact in real-time with your audience, answering questions and discussing topics of interest, which can significantly boost engagement.
- Optimize Posting Times: Post when your audience is most active to ensure maximum visibility and engagement with your content.
These strategies are designed to help Instagram influencers enhance their engagement rate, fostering a vibrant and engaging community around their brand and content.
How to use the engagement rate calculator to find influencers for your brand
Using an engagement rate calculator can significantly streamline the process of finding the right influencers for your brand by providing a quantifiable measure of an influencer’s ability to engage their audience. Before wasting time on negotiation and influencer reach out, simply type in the influencer in our free Instagram engagement rate checker and make sure that the influencer has a good engagemet rate. We typically recommend an engagement rate of 2% and higher when working with influencers.